Explore Brands Perfumers Notes Reviews Community Tools Fragrance Expert

⌘K

Fraganty

The open encyclopedic fragrance database. Built for humans and AI.

Browse

All Perfumes
Brands
Perfumers
Notes
Best Perfumes
Dupes & Alternatives
Community
Tools
Insights

Developers

API Documentation
Endpoints
Pricing
Playground
Open Data

For AI

llms.txt
REST API
Sitemap

Popular

Top Rated
Most Popular
Perfumes from 2025
Perfumes from 2024

Company

About Fraganty
Advertise
Contact
Terms of Service
Privacy Policy
Cookie Policy

Perfumes Similar to Carnivale by Brown Girl Jane | Fraganty

Home/Carnivale/Similar Fragrances

Perfumes Similar to Carnivale

Name: Carnivale
Brand: Brown Girl Jane
Rating: 4.09 (195 reviews)

12 fragrances with similar scent profiles to Carnivale by Brown Girl Jane — rated 4.1/5

Brown Girl Jane

Carnivale

SweetTropicalFruityVanillaPowdery

4.1/5

Similar Fragrances

Kayali Fragrances

Vanilla Candy Rock Sugar | 42

4.02024

Burberry

Burberry Her Elixir de Parfum

4.12022Elixir

Sponsored

Kayali Fragrances

Yum Boujee Marshmallow | 81

4.3Buy on Amazon

Sponsored

Kayali Fragrances

The Wedding Silk Santal | 36

4.2Buy on Amazon

Sponsored

By Kilian

I Don't Need A Prince By My Side To Be A Princess

4.2Buy on Amazon

Sponsored

Brown Girl Jane

Carousel

4.2Buy on Amazon

Ellis Brooklyn

Miami Nectar

4.22024

Kayali Fragrances

Yum Boujee Marshmallow | 81

4.32024

Kayali Fragrances

The Wedding Silk Santal | 36

4.22023

Kayali Fragrances

Eden Juicy Apple | 01 Eau De Parfum

3.92021Eau de Parfum

By Kilian

I Don't Need A Prince By My Side To Be A Princess

4.22018

Brown Girl Jane

Carousel

4.22024

Kayali Fragrances

Yum Pistachio Gelato | 33

3.82023

By Kilian

Love Don't Be Shy

4.02007

Kayali Fragrances

Vanilla | 28

4.22018

Dolce Gabbana

Devotion Dolce&Gabbana perfume

4.02023

Frequently asked questions

What perfumes are similar to Carnivale?+

Fragrances with the closest accord profile to Carnivale by Brown Girl Jane: Vanilla Candy Rock Sugar | 42 by Kayali Fragrances; Burberry Her Elixir de Parfum by Burberry; Miami Nectar by Ellis Brooklyn. Each is selected by cosine similarity on accord strengths and shared notes.

Why are these perfumes considered similar?+

Similarity is computed from three signals: (1) cosine similarity between accord strength vectors, (2) Jaccard overlap on note sets across the pyramid, (3) a curated "often compared to" list from community mentions. The top matches blend all three.

Which notes drive the Carnivale profile?+

Carnivale's opening signature comes from Mango, Agave Nectar, Jasmine. Similar perfumes usually carry at least 2 of these same top notes alongside matching heart accords.

Community Sentiment Pulse — Carnivale

Negative

26 opinions · Source: r/fragrance community

3.5

/10

Carnivale by Brown Girl Jane received minimal discussion in the fragrance community, mentioned only once among a batch of disappointing samples. The fragrance appears to fall into the category of popular but unremarkable designer-style scents that lack longevity and uniqueness, with the original poster lumping it with other underwhelming fragrances that remind them of mass-market alternatives.

Positive

Tropical/fruity scent profile
Potentially crowd-pleasing for some
Part of an emerging indie brand

Negative

Poor longevity and performance
Compared unfavorably to Bath & Body Works quality
Not distinctive or unique enough
Fails to impress fragrance enthusiasts

Best For

Not recommended by community consensus