Question 1

What's the difference between Sumatera and Noir de Noir?

Accepted Answer

Sumatera is a feminine fragrance (marketed to women, though wearable by all) from Coquillete (2012) dominated by Warm Spicy accords. Noir de Noir is a feminine fragrance (marketed to women, though wearable by all) from Tom Ford (2007) leaning on Earthy accords. They share 4 accords: Warm Spicy, Patchouli, Woody, Vanilla.

Question 2

Which is better, Sumatera or Noir de Noir?

Accepted Answer

By community rating, Sumatera scores 3.57/5 vs Noir de Noir at 4.32/5. Noir de Noir's standout strength: Unique dark floral composition with roses, chocolate, and earthy patchouli notes. The "better" choice depends on what you value — longevity, projection, season fit, or signature character.

Question 3

Do Sumatera and Noir de Noir smell similar?

Accepted Answer

They share 2 notes and 4 accords, including Warm Spicy, Patchouli, Woody, Vanilla, Patchouli. Noir de Noir: Noir de Noir is a deeply polarizing Tom Ford fragrance with devoted fans who love its dark, complex floral character, but it suffers from significant performance issues in recent batches.

Question 4

Which lasts longer, Sumatera or Noir de Noir?

Accepted Answer

Noir de Noir: Recent batches reported to have significantly weaker performance and longevity Longevity varies by skin chemistry, concentration, and application method.

Question 5

Which season suits Sumatera vs Noir de Noir?

Accepted Answer

Sumatera scores highest for winter wear; Noir de Noir scores highest for winter wear. Sumatera leans evening, Noir de Noir leans evening.

Sumatera vs Noir de Noir

Comparison Summary

Shared Notes (2)

Unique to Sumatera (6)

Unique to Noir de Noir (6)

Shared Accords (4)

Frequently asked questions

Community Sentiment Pulse — Noir de Noir

Positive

Negative

Attribute	Sumatera	Noir de Noir
Brand	Coquillete	Tom Ford
Year	2012	2007
Rating	3.57	4.32
Concentration	—	—
Gender	feminine	feminine
Total Notes	10	8