Side-by-side comparison of Sellier by Byredo and Black Afgano by Nasomatto
Byredo
Nasomatto
| Attribute | Sellier | Black Afgano |
|---|---|---|
| Brand | Byredo | Nasomatto |
| Year | 2019 | 2009 |
| Rating | 4.12 | 4.06 |
| Concentration | — | — |
| Gender | feminine | feminine |
| Total Notes | 6 | 23 |
26 opinions · Source: r/fragrance community
7.8
/10
The r/fragrance community views Sellier very positively as a sophisticated smoky-woody fragrance with impressive longevity, though many acknowledge it as a superior but considerably more expensive alternative to By the Fireplace. The main criticism centers on Byredo's unjustifiable $300+ price tag for what some consider basic minimalist packaging, making it aspirational rather than accessible for most collectors.
68 opinions · Source: r/fragrance community
6.2
/10
Black Afgano is a divisive fragrance with genuine admirers and vocal detractors. While it's praised for its artistry, complexity, and impressive construction, many find it impractical for everyday wear due to its challenging character and the cannabis-like notes that could be inappropriate in certain contexts. Recent reformulations have disappointed long-time fans with diminished performance, and the premium pricing limits its accessibility.