Side-by-side comparison of Rosa Gardenia by Santa Maria Novella and Carnal Flower by Frederic Malle
Santa Maria Novella
Frederic Malle
| Attribute | Rosa Gardenia | Carnal Flower |
|---|---|---|
| Brand | Santa Maria Novella | Frederic Malle |
| Year | 2021 | 2005 |
| Rating | 3.57 | 4.16 |
| Concentration | — | — |
| Gender | feminine | feminine |
| Total Notes | 10 | 12 |
5 opinions · Source: r/fragrance community
6.5
/10
Rosa Gardenia and similar centifolia rose fragrances are highly praised for their soft, plush quality and authentic rose character, but the fragrance community acknowledges significant challenges with availability and cost. Multiple users recommend alternatives like Penhaligon's Elisabethan Rose, Frederic Malle's Lipstick Rose, and Diptyque Eau Rose as comparable options, though sourcing quality centifolia rose scents remains difficult.
57 opinions · Source: r/fragrance community
8.7
/10
Carnal Flower is overwhelmingly praised by the r/fragrance community as a masterpiece floral fragrance with a unique dirty, sensual character. The fragrance is celebrated for its complexity, versatility, and quality, with many users describing it as a transformative discovery that justifies its premium price point. The main drawback is accessibility and the prevalence of counterfeits, which the community recommends avoiding through official retailers.