Skip to main content
Fraganty
Explore
Brands
Perfumers
Notes
Reviews
Community
Tools
Fragrance Expert
⌘
K
en
Home
/
Compare
Return vs Idylle
Side-by-side comparison of Return by Panouge and Idylle by Guerlain
Panouge
Return
1990
feminine
3.77
(22)
Accords
White Floral
100%
Green
88%
Floral
86%
Yellow Floral
48%
Musky
40%
Fresh
39%
Top
Narcissus
Lily Of The Valley
Palm Leaf
Heart
Freesia
Gardenia
Rose
Base
Musk
Black Currant
Oakmoss
Best: Spring (55%)
Day (100%)
Guerlain
Idylle
2009
feminine
3.79
(6,753)
Accords
White Floral
100%
Floral
93%
Fresh
71%
Rose
50%
Musky
32%
Green
31%
Top
Rose
Freesia
Litchi
Raspberry
Heart
Lily Of The Valley
Jasmine
Lilac
Peony
Lily
Base
Musk
Patchouli
Best: Spring (94%)
Day (100%)
Comparison Summary
Shared Notes (4)
Lily Of The Valley
Freesia
Rose
Musk
Unique to Return (5)
Narcissus
Palm Leaf
Gardenia
Black Currant
Oakmoss
Unique to Idylle (7)
Litchi
Raspberry
Jasmine
Lilac
Peony
Lily
Patchouli
Shared Accords (6)
White Floral
Green
Floral
Musky
Fresh
Rose
Attribute
Return
Idylle
Brand
Panouge
Guerlain
Year
1990
2009
Rating
3.77
3.79
Concentration
—
—
Gender
feminine
feminine
Total Notes
9
11