Not Your Baby vs Eilish

Not Your Baby receives mixed-to-negative feedback from the community, with most agreeing that while the opening is appealing and sweet, the fragrance suffers from disappointing longevity and problematic drydown characteristics. Multiple reviewers note baby powder, playdoh, or lactonic undertones that persist, and the consensus is that the price point cannot be justified given the poor performance and limited wear time.

Eilish by Billie Eilish is a competent but unremarkable vanilla fragrance that benefits from celebrity hype rather than exceptional quality. While it performs adequately with good sillage and receives compliments, it lacks longevity and originality, representing the oversaturated TikTok-driven fragrance market that the community is increasingly skeptical of.