Skip to main content
Fraganty
Explore
Brands
Perfumers
Notes
Reviews
Community
Tools
Fragrance Expert
⌘
K
en
Home
/
Compare
Malesia vs Black Phantom
Side-by-side comparison of Malesia by Xerjoff and Black Phantom by By Kilian
Xerjoff
Malesia
feminine
4.20
(379)
Accords
Amber
100%
Woody
53%
Oud
52%
Powdery
43%
Vanilla
34%
Musky
30%
Top
Lily Of The Valley
Heart
Amber
Gurjun Balsam
Base
Laotian Oud
Tolu Balsam
Labdanum
Vanilla
Musk
Tonka Bean
Day (0%)
By Kilian
Black Phantom
2017
feminine
4.08
(9,611)
Accords
Sweet
100%
Warm Spicy
87%
Caramel
53%
Chocolate
52%
Coffee
52%
Rum
47%
Top
Rum
Heart
Dark Chocolate
Coffee
Almond
Heliotrope
Base
Caramel
Sugar
Sandalwood
Vanilla
Tonka Bean
Vetiver
Best: Winter (100%)
Night (89%)
Comparison Summary
Shared Notes (2)
Vanilla
Tonka Bean
Unique to Malesia (7)
Lily Of The Valley
Amber
Gurjun Balsam
Laotian Oud
Tolu Balsam
Labdanum
Musk
Unique to Black Phantom (9)
Rum
Dark Chocolate
Coffee
Almond
Heliotrope
Caramel
Sugar
Sandalwood
Vetiver
Shared Accords (2)
Woody
Sweet
Attribute
Malesia
Black Phantom
Brand
Xerjoff
By Kilian
Year
—
2017
Rating
4.20
4.08
Concentration
—
—
Gender
feminine
feminine
Total Notes
9
11