Makiling vs Eclat Noir

Side-by-side comparison of Makiling by Parfums Astraux and Eclat Noir by GP Fragrances

Makiling

Parfums Astraux

2023feminine

4.62(13)

Accords

Floral

100%

Mossy

29%

Woody

25%

Earthy

25%

Tropical

23%

Green

22%

Best: Spring (100%)Day (100%)

Eclat Noir

GP Fragrances

2025feminine

4.38(48)

Accords

Woody

100%

Warm Spicy

95%

Sweet

85%

Cherry

78%

Cacao

76%

Vanilla

68%

Top

Heart

Cognac Cacao Pod

Base

Vanilla Amber Patchouli

Best: Winter (100%)Night (94%)

Comparison Summary

Unique to Eclat Noir (7)

Cherry Cedar Cognac Cacao Pod Vanilla Amber Patchouli

Shared Accords (1)

Woody

Attribute	Makiling	Eclat Noir
Brand	Parfums Astraux	GP Fragrances
Year	2023	2025
Rating	4.62	4.38
Concentration	—	—
Gender	feminine	feminine
Total Notes	0	7