Side-by-side comparison of Italica by Xerjoff and Black Phantom by By Kilian
Xerjoff
By Kilian
| Attribute | Italica | Black Phantom |
|---|---|---|
| Brand | Xerjoff | By Kilian |
| Year | 2016 | 2017 |
| Rating | 4.04 | 4.08 |
| Concentration | — | — |
| Gender | feminine | feminine |
| Total Notes | 8 | 11 |
46 opinions · Source: r/fragrance community
5.8
/10
Italica is a polarizing fragrance that works beautifully for gourmand lovers who perceive the almond cake, milk, and toffee notes as intended, but disappoints those who detect fruity/cherry or medicinal qualities instead. While praised for packaging and projection, it suffers from weak longevity and questionable performance relative to its price point, making sampling before purchase highly recommended.
83 opinions · Source: r/fragrance community
6.2
/10
Black Phantom is a divisive gourmand fragrance with strong performance that appeals to some but disappoints others who find it too cloying and overly hyped. Community members appreciate its unique rum and burned sugar character but note it often underperforms against expectations set by its reputation.