Question 1

What's the difference between Immortelle black and Promise?

Accepted Answer

Immortelle black is a feminine fragrance (marketed to women, though wearable by all) from Incarna parfums (2021) dominated by Woody accords. Promise is a feminine fragrance (marketed to women, though wearable by all) from Frederic Malle (2017) leaning on Woody accords. They share 3 accords: Woody, Amber, Fruity.

Question 2

Which is better, Immortelle black or Promise?

Accepted Answer

By community rating, Immortelle black scores 4.22/5 vs Promise at 4.21/5. Promise's standout strength: Unique and distinctive rose fragrance with no actual oud. The "better" choice depends on what you value — longevity, projection, season fit, or signature character.

Question 3

Do Immortelle black and Promise smell similar?

Accepted Answer

They share a small fraction of their ingredients — expect noticeably different experiences. Promise: Promise is widely praised as a masterpiece rose fragrance with exceptional character and uniqueness, earning strong loyalty from both new and experienced fragrance collectors.

Question 4

Which lasts longer, Immortelle black or Promise?

Accepted Answer

Promise: Not office-appropriate for some due to projection Longevity varies by skin chemistry, concentration, and application method.

Question 5

Which season suits Immortelle black vs Promise?

Accepted Answer

Immortelle black scores highest for fall wear; Promise scores highest for winter wear. Immortelle black leans evening, Promise leans evening.

Immortelle black vs Promise

Comparison Summary

Unique to Promise (11)

Shared Accords (3)

Frequently asked questions

Community Sentiment Pulse — Promise

Positive

Negative

Attribute	Immortelle black	Promise
Brand	Incarna parfums	Frederic Malle
Year	2021	2017
Rating	4.22	4.21
Concentration	—	—
Gender	feminine	feminine
Total Notes	0	12