Guerlain Homme vs Bleu de Chanel

Guerlain Homme EDP is a polarizing underrated fragrance that impresses those who appreciate its unique mojito accord and smooth drydown, though it's held back by weak performance and questionable reformulations. The community appreciates its originality and versatility but acknowledges it falls in an awkward space between typical Guerlain offerings and mainstream fresh fragrances, with older formulations considered superior to current bottles.

The r/fragrance community largely views Bleu de Chanel as an excellent designer fragrance that deserves its popularity, with particular praise for the EDP and Parfum versions. While some find it overhyped or prefer alternative fragrances, most agree it's a reliable, well-balanced everyday scent that belongs in any collection as a versatile baseline. The consensus is that it's popular because it genuinely performs well, not just due to marketing hype.