Skip to main content
Fraganty
Explore
Brands
Perfumers
Notes
Reviews
Community
Tools
Fragrance Expert
⌘
K
en
Home
/
Compare
Comma vs L'Instant Magic
Side-by-side comparison of Comma by Comma and L'Instant Magic by Guerlain
Comma
Comma
2004
feminine
4.60
(5)
Accords
Woody
100%
Powdery
87%
Musky
58%
Iris
50%
Fruity
50%
Floral
47%
Top
Black Currant
Bergamot
Galbanum
Heart
Iris
Cyclamen
Jasmine
Tuberose
Base
Musk
Sandalwood
Palisander Rosewood
Cedar
Amber
Best: Fall (100%)
Day (100%)
Guerlain
L'Instant Magic
2007
feminine
4.23
(5,950)
Accords
Powdery
100%
Floral
61%
Violet
58%
Almond
46%
Iris
46%
Sweet
41%
Top
Anise
Bergamot
Lemon
Heart
Violet
Mimosa
Rose
Freesia
Carnation
Base
Almond
Iris
Vanilla
Musk
Sandalwood
Cedar
Best: Winter (100%)
Day (93%)
Comparison Summary
Shared Notes (5)
Bergamot
Iris
Musk
Sandalwood
Cedar
Unique to Comma (7)
Black Currant
Galbanum
Cyclamen
Jasmine
Tuberose
Palisander Rosewood
Amber
Unique to L'Instant Magic (9)
Anise
Lemon
Violet
Mimosa
Rose
Freesia
Carnation
Almond
Vanilla
Shared Accords (5)
Woody
Powdery
Musky
Iris
Floral
Attribute
Comma
L'Instant Magic
Brand
Comma
Guerlain
Year
2004
2007
Rating
4.60
4.23
Concentration
—
—
Gender
feminine
feminine
Total Notes
12
14