Skip to main content
Fraganty
Explore
Brands
Perfumers
Notes
Reviews
Community
Tools
Fragrance Expert
⌘
K
en
Home
/
Compare
Carnelian vs Ciara
Side-by-side comparison of Carnelian by Vartan Perfumes and Ciara by Revlon
Vartan Perfumes
Carnelian
2015
feminine
4.33
(12)
Accords
Warm Spicy
100%
Amber
57%
Cinnamon
54%
Aromatic
50%
Floral
43%
Vanilla
43%
Top
Cinnamon
Pepper
Heart
Carnation
White Tobacco
Vetiver
Base
Amber
Vanilla
Tonka Bean
Best: Winter (100%)
Day (60%)
Revlon
Ciara
1973
feminine
3.94
(1,752)
Accords
Amber
100%
Balsamic
80%
Sweet
76%
Woody
75%
Smoky
55%
Powdery
37%
Top
Raspberry
Neroli
Bergamot
Lemon
Heart
Brazilian Rosewood
Ylang Ylang
Orris Root
Jasmine
Palmarosa
Base
Opoponax
Incense
Leather
Vanilla
Musk
Cedar
Best: Fall (100%)
Night (90%)
Comparison Summary
Shared Notes (1)
Vanilla
Unique to Carnelian (7)
Cinnamon
Pepper
Carnation
White Tobacco
Vetiver
Amber
Tonka Bean
Unique to Ciara (14)
Raspberry
Neroli
Bergamot
Lemon
Brazilian Rosewood
Ylang Ylang
Orris Root
Jasmine
Palmarosa
Opoponax
Incense
Leather
Musk
Cedar
Shared Accords (2)
Amber
Vanilla
Attribute
Carnelian
Ciara
Brand
Vartan Perfumes
Revlon
Year
2015
1973
Rating
4.33
3.94
Concentration
—
—
Gender
feminine
feminine
Total Notes
8
15