Bellodgia Extrait vs Joy

The community appreciates the list for highlighting lesser-known fragrances with devoted followings, but questions its statistical validity due to low sample sizes and potential rating bias toward extrait versions. Many note the fragrances are difficult to obtain and primarily of interest to seasoned collectors rather than general fragrance consumers.

Joy by Jean Patou is widely respected within the fragrance community as a legendary classic worthy of inclusion on must-smell lists. Community members praise its iconic status, longevity, and elegant composition, though some note it requires familiarity to fully appreciate and comes at a premium price.