The A*Men line generates divided opinions, with the original formulation and Pure Havane flanker highly regarded, while recent releases like Stellar and Ultimate disappoint long-time fans. Community consensus indicates the line excels for evening wear in cooler seasons but struggles with versatility and summer compatibility, with notable quality decline in newer releases compared to vintage versions.
Positive
Original A*Men formulation has strong silage and longevity
Pure Havane is versatile and receives consistent praise for complexity
Kryptomint offers unique mint-chocolate character reminiscent of Andes Mints
Brand responsive to customer inquiries and sample requests
Negative
Recent flankers (Stellar, Ultimate) perceived as weak, generic, and underwhelming compared to original
Frequently asked questions
What's the difference between Bay Rum C.O.Bigelow cologne and A*Men?+
Bay Rum C.O.Bigelow cologne is a masculine fragrance (marketed to men, though wearable by all) from C O Bigelow (undated) dominated by Warm Spicy accords. A*Men is a masculine fragrance (marketed to men, though wearable by all) from Mugler (1996) leaning on Warm Spicy accords. They share 1 accord: Warm Spicy.
Which is better, Bay Rum C.O.Bigelow cologne or A*Men?+
By community rating, Bay Rum C.O.Bigelow cologne scores 4.06/5 vs A*Men at 4.02/5. A*Men's standout strength: Original A*Men formulation has strong silage and longevity. The "better" choice depends on what you value — longevity, projection, season fit, or signature character.
Do Bay Rum C.O.Bigelow cologne and A*Men smell similar?+
They share a small fraction of their ingredients — expect noticeably different experiences. A*Men: The A*Men line generates divided opinions, with the original formulation and Pure Havane flanker highly regarded, while recent releases like Stellar and Ultimate disappoint long-time fans.
Which lasts longer, Bay Rum C.O.Bigelow cologne or A*Men?+
A*Men: Original A*Men formulation has strong silage and longevity Longevity varies by skin chemistry, concentration, and application method.
Which season suits Bay Rum C.O.Bigelow cologne vs A*Men?+
Bay Rum C.O.Bigelow cologne scores highest for winter wear; A*Men scores highest for winter wear. Bay Rum C.O.Bigelow cologne leans daytime, A*Men leans evening.
Pure Malt is overhyped, too linear, and lacks versatility for daily wear
Overall A*Men line DNA not suitable for warm weather or daytime wear
Quality concerns with newer releases compared to vintage formulations
