Side-by-side comparison of Apple Brandy on the Rocks by By Kilian and Noir Extreme by Tom Ford
By Kilian
Tom Ford
| Attribute | Apple Brandy on the Rocks | Noir Extreme |
|---|---|---|
| Brand | By Kilian | Tom Ford |
| Year | 2021 | 2015 |
| Rating | 4.12 | 4.43 |
| Concentration | — | — |
| Gender | feminine | masculine |
| Total Notes | 10 | 14 |
44 opinions · Source: r/fragrance community
6.5
/10
Apple Brandy On The Rocks features an impressive, realistic crisp apple opening that captures a unique brandy cocktail concept, but suffers from short longevity and an overly prominent smoky drydown that some find off-putting. Community consensus is divided—those who appreciate the novelty concept and smoky warmth appreciate it, while others find the smokiness too intense and the short-lived apple note disappointing.
44 opinions · Source: r/fragrance community
6.8
/10
Tom Ford Noir Extreme receives mixed community feedback. While praised for its luxurious, sophisticated scent profile and excellent longevity on compatible skin types, significant performance variation across individuals and a premium price point make it a fragrance requiring testing before purchase. Community consensus suggests it excels as a fall/winter scent for special occasions rather than casual daily wear.