Winter 24 vs Summer 24

Winter 24 receives divided opinions with customers appreciating its artistic packaging and concept but struggling with weak longevity and divisive scent character. While some find it elegantly cozy and winter-appropriate, others find it too grandmotherly or similar to previous releases, leading to frequent returns despite the brand's positive sustainability practices and customer service.

Summer 24 receives mixed reviews centered on a critical longevity issue. While the scent itself is appreciated by many for its citrus-sandalwood opening and pleasant development, it consistently fades within 1-2 hours, making the premium price difficult to justify. Several users report unwanted powdery or Play-Doh notes emerging quickly, though this varies by individual skin chemistry.