The Key vs Midnight Fantasy

The Key by Justin Bieber is a discontinued fragrance that generated strong nostalgia among those who wore it during its 2012-2013 peak. While some community members report finding it at select U.S. mall locations, international availability is severely limited and secondary market prices are prohibitively expensive, making it challenging for former fans to repurchase.

Midnight Fantasy is a polarizing budget fragrance that delivers on longevity and price but disappoints many with its synthetic, shampoo-like character. While some appreciate it for the value and occasional compliments, the community consensus notes it smells noticeably inexpensive compared to other celebrity fragrances, making it better suited for younger wearers or those unconcerned with fragrance quality perception.