The r/fragrance community views Dossier as a solid budget option with hit-or-miss results depending on the specific dupe. While their Tom Ford recreations and Jo Malone alternatives receive consistent praise for longevity and value, some dupes fail to capture the original's dry down or character. Quality and performance improve after the scents age for a month or so.
正面
Excellent longevity and performance compared to Jo Malone
High quality dupes of Tom Ford scents at fraction of the price
Good value for money with multiple successful fragrances
Scent profile improves and mellows after aging
负面
Inconsistent quality across different dupes - some don't match originals well
Can smell overpowering when brand new
社区情绪脉搏 — You
中性
96 条评价 · 来源：r/fragrance 社区
5.2
/10
Glossier You is divisive in the fragrance community, primarily due to its post-reformulation performance. While the scent profile itself receives praise for being pleasant and wearable, the drastically reduced longevity (often just minutes to hours) makes it a poor value at its premium price point. Performance varies significantly between individuals, with some reporting all-day wear while others describe it as a fleeting whisper, creating widespread frustration about quality control.
正面
Pleasant, appealing scent profile with subtle skin scent quality
Good for those who prefer non-projecting fragrances
Performs well on some individuals despite reformulation
Receives genuine compliments from others hours after application
负面
Severe longevity issues post-reformulation (2 minutes to 1 hour for many users)
Poor longevity for the high price point ($72-100)
常见问题
What's the difference between Musky Musk and You?+
Musky Musk is a feminine fragrance (marketed to women, though wearable by all) from Dossier (2010) dominated by Musky accords. You is a feminine fragrance (marketed to women, though wearable by all) from Glossier (2017) leaning on Musky accords. They share 3 accords: Musky, Amber, Powdery.
麝香
100%
木质
71%
琥珀
69%
粉质
25%
芳香树脂
19%
动物性
15%
最佳: Spring (96%)Day (100%)
麝香
100%
鸢尾
85%
琥珀
59%
粉质
51%
温和辛香
49%
紫罗兰
42%
最佳: Spring (90%)Day (100%)
Which is better, Musky Musk or You?+
By community rating, Musky Musk scores 4.33/5 vs You at 4.14/5. On r/fragrance, Musky Musk sits at 7.2/10 (mixed) while You is 5.2/10 (mixed). Musky Musk's standout strength: Excellent longevity and performance compared to Jo Malone. You's standout strength: Pleasant, appealing scent profile with subtle skin scent quality. The "better" choice depends on what you value — longevity, projection, season fit, or signature character.
Do Musky Musk and You smell similar?+
They share a small fraction of their ingredients — expect noticeably different experiences. Musky Musk: The r/fragrance community views Dossier as a solid budget option with hit-or-miss results depending on the specific dupe. You: Glossier You is divisive in the fragrance community, primarily due to its post-reformulation performance.
Which lasts longer, Musky Musk or You?+
Musky Musk: Excellent longevity and performance compared to Jo Malone You: Receives genuine compliments from others hours after application Longevity varies by skin chemistry, concentration, and application method.
Which season suits Musky Musk vs You?+
Musky Musk scores highest for spring wear; You scores highest for spring wear. Musky Musk leans daytime, You leans daytime.
Dry down often differs significantly from original fragrances
Company uses deceptive pricing practices with fake sales
Inconsistent performance across product formats and individuals
Reformulation widely considered inferior to original formula
