Jo Malone London Melancholy Thistle 与 Serge Lutens Chergui 的并列对比
Jo Malone London
2023feminine
3.99(155)
主调
Serge Lutens
2001feminine
4.23(12,351)
主调
对比摘要
共同主调（2）
木质绿色
属性
Melancholy Thistle
Chergui
品牌
Jo Malone London
Serge Lutens
年份
2023
2001
评分
3.99
4.23
浓度
—
—
性别
feminine
feminine
香调总数
0
0
社区情绪脉搏 — Chergui
中性
58 条评价 · 来源：r/fragrance 社区
7.2
/10
Chergui is a well-crafted but divisive fragrance with a distinctive powdery tobacco profile that appeals strongly to its admirers but isn't universally loved. The community consensus leans positive overall, though most agree it's not a safe blind buy given its niche character and high price point, recommending sampling first, especially if coming from different fragrance families like Ambre Sultan.
正面
Unique powdery tobacco blend with pleasant hay notes
Excellent performance and longevity in cooler weather
Highly regarded by Serge Lutens enthusiasts and loyal fans
Versatile unisex appeal, works well for both men and women
负面
Noticeably powdery character that some find off-putting or baby powder-like
Not similar to Ambre Sultan despite both being amber fragrances
常见问题
What's the difference between Melancholy Thistle and Chergui?+
Melancholy Thistle is a feminine fragrance (marketed to women, though wearable by all) from Jo Malone London (2023) dominated by Woody accords. Chergui is a feminine fragrance (marketed to women, though wearable by all) from Serge Lutens (2001) leaning on Amber accords. They share 2 accords: Woody, Green.
木质
100%
绿色
85%
草本
45%
广藿香
45%
清新
43%
臭氧
36%
最佳: Spring (100%)Day (84%)
琥珀
100%
甜
85%
烟草
80%
蜂蜜
77%
粉质
60%
木质
48%
最佳: Fall (100%)Night (81%)
Which is better, Melancholy Thistle or Chergui?
+
By community rating, Melancholy Thistle scores 3.99/5 vs Chergui at 4.23/5. Chergui's standout strength: Unique powdery tobacco blend with pleasant hay notes. The "better" choice depends on what you value — longevity, projection, season fit, or signature character.
Do Melancholy Thistle and Chergui smell similar?+
They share a small fraction of their ingredients — expect noticeably different experiences. Chergui: Chergui is a well-crafted but divisive fragrance with a distinctive powdery tobacco profile that appeals strongly to its admirers but isn't universally loved.
Which lasts longer, Melancholy Thistle or Chergui?+
Chergui: Excellent performance and longevity in cooler weather Longevity varies by skin chemistry, concentration, and application method.
Which season suits Melancholy Thistle vs Chergui?+
Melancholy Thistle scores highest for spring wear; Chergui scores highest for fall wear. Melancholy Thistle leans daytime, Chergui leans evening.
Old-fashioned scent profile that may not appeal to all preferences
Too expensive and niche to recommend as a blind buy without sampling first
