Halston 1-12 vs Polo

Halston 1-12 is celebrated by the r/fragrance community as a massively underrated budget gem with excellent longevity and performance for its price. While the green, soapy aromatic character is beloved by many who grew up with it, some users report inconsistent batches or find the smoky character off-putting, making it somewhat polarizing despite its cult status.

The Polo line by Ralph Lauren receives mixed reviews from the r/fragrance community. While recognized as accessible entry-level fragrances with decent quality, many experienced enthusiasts find the original scents plain or generic compared to niche alternatives. Specific flankers like Polo Blue Gold Blend and Ultra Blue attract more enthusiasm, though some users actively avoid the brand due to overexposure in casual party settings.