Autumn 24 vs Summer 24

The r/fragrance community consensus is strongly negative on Autumn 24, with multiple users reporting it fails to deliver on marketing promises of quince and balanced spices. The fragrance is dominated by patchouli and cedar, perceived as overly masculine, and described as sickly-sweet with rotten fruit character that caused several users to immediately wash it off due to headaches and nausea.

Summer 24 receives mixed reviews centered on a critical longevity issue. While the scent itself is appreciated by many for its citrus-sandalwood opening and pleasant development, it consistently fades within 1-2 hours, making the premium price difficult to justify. Several users report unwanted powdery or Play-Doh notes emerging quickly, though this varies by individual skin chemistry.