Saint Julep has an appealing concept and creative opening with minty-sugary notes, but the r/fragrance community consensus is that poor longevity and a disappointing drydown make it difficult to recommend as a full bottle purchase. While some appreciate its uniqueness and a few report better performance, the general view is that Imaginary Authors' marketing and presentation exceed the actual fragrance quality, especially given niche pricing.
正面
Unique and interesting opening with minty, sugary, boozy character
Appealing concept inspired by Southern US culture and literature
Strong creative marketing and storytelling from Imaginary Authors
Pleasant mint and clementine notes that some find enjoyable
负面
Poor longevity and projection - fades quickly on most wearers
Cannot be resprayed, limiting reapplication
常见问题
What's the difference between 5:00 PM and Saint Julep?+
5:00 PM is a feminine fragrance (marketed to women, though wearable by all) from HOC (2019) dominated by Green accords. Saint Julep is a feminine fragrance (marketed to women, though wearable by all) from Imaginary Authors (2017) leaning on Sweet accords. They share 3 accords: Green, Sweet, Fresh Spicy.
绿色
100%
麝香
61%
清新
50%
甜
36%
臭氧
33%
粉质
30%
最佳: Spring (90%)Day (100%)
甜
100%
绿色
85%
柑橘
73%
芳香
55%
Whiskey
41%
清新辛香
39%
最佳: Summer (100%)Day (93%)
Which is better, 5:00 PM or Saint Julep?
+
By community rating, 5:00 PM scores 4.28/5 vs Saint Julep at 4.01/5. Saint Julep's standout strength: Unique and interesting opening with minty, sugary, boozy character. The "better" choice depends on what you value — longevity, projection, season fit, or signature character.
Do 5:00 PM and Saint Julep smell similar?+
They share a small fraction of their ingredients — expect noticeably different experiences. Saint Julep: Saint Julep has an appealing concept and creative opening with minty-sugary notes, but the r/fragrance community consensus is that poor longevity and a disappointing drydown make it difficult to recommend as a full bottle purchase.
Which lasts longer, 5:00 PM or Saint Julep?+
Saint Julep: Poor longevity and projection - fades quickly on most wearers Longevity varies by skin chemistry, concentration, and application method.
Which season suits 5:00 PM vs Saint Julep?+
5:00 PM scores highest for spring wear; Saint Julep scores highest for summer wear. 5:00 PM leans daytime, Saint Julep leans daytime.
Muddled, underwhelming drydown that doesn't justify the price
High niche pricing not matched by fragrance quality
