Return vs Idylle

Порівняння Return від Panouge та Idylle від Guerlain пліч-о-пліч

Panouge

1990feminine

3.77(22)

Акорди

Guerlain

2009feminine

3.79(6,753)

Акорди

Підсумок порівняння

Спільні акорди (6)

БілоквітковийЗеленийКвітковийМускуснийСвіжийТрояндовий

Властивість	Return	Idylle
Бренд	Panouge	Guerlain
Рік	1990	2009
Оцінка	3.77	3.79
Концентрація	—	—
Стать	feminine	feminine
Усього нот	9	11

Часті запитання

What's the difference between Return and Idylle?+

Return is a feminine fragrance (marketed to women, though wearable by all) from Panouge (1990) dominated by White Floral accords. Idylle is a feminine fragrance (marketed to women, though wearable by all) from Guerlain (2009) leaning on White Floral accords. They share 6 accords: White Floral, Green, Floral, Musky.

Which is better, Return or Idylle?+

By community rating, Return scores 3.77/5 vs Idylle at 3.79/5. Idylle's standout strength: Beautiful, floral, and airy scent with a fairy-like quality. The "better" choice depends on what you value — longevity, projection, season fit, or signature character.

Do Return and Idylle smell similar?+

They share 4 notes and 6 accords, including White Floral, Green, Floral, Musky, Fresh. Idylle: The r/fragrance community views Guerlain Idylle positively as a gorgeous, well-blended floral fragrance with an airy, feminine character.

Which lasts longer, Return or Idylle?+

Longevity varies by skin chemistry, concentration, and application method.

Which season suits Return vs Idylle?+

Return scores highest for spring wear; Idylle scores highest for spring wear. Return leans daytime, Idylle leans daytime.

Пульс настроїв спільноти — Idylle

Позитивний

60 думок · Джерело: спільнота r/fragrance

7.5

/10

The r/fragrance community views Guerlain Idylle positively as a gorgeous, well-blended floral fragrance with an airy, feminine character. While it shares some opening similarities with Narciso Rodriguez For Her, users note it's distinctly different and more floral. The main criticism involves its greenness that emerges beyond the initial spray, and some find the flankers overly sweet.

Позитивний

Beautiful, floral, and airy scent with a fairy-like quality
Well-blended and elegant composition typical of Guerlain
Distinct from similar fragrances despite initial comparisons

Негативний

Noticeable greenness that develops after initial wearing
Flanker version (Jasmin-Lilas) reported as too sweet for some
Can be forgettable on first sampling

Return vs Idylle

Підсумок порівняння

Спільні ноти (4)

Унікальні для Return (5)

Унікальні для Idylle (7)

Спільні акорди (6)

Часті запитання

Позитивний

Негативний