Parisian vs Amber Aoud

The community views Xerjoff's 2023 releases as competently made but underwhelming, lacking the must-have appeal of established releases. While quality craftsmanship is acknowledged, the fragrances are considered challenging to incorporate into daily rotation due to their occasion-specific nature and the brand's lack of clear identity.

Amber Aoud by Roja Dove is regarded as a quality luxury fragrance with strong performance, but community members express concern about its premium pricing and misleading marketing around the 'amber' note. Despite the high cost, those who own it appreciate it as a special, collectible fragrance.