Indochine (2019) vs Mamluk

Indochine appears to be a divisive Xerjoff fragrance with a compelling opening and drydown, but an awkward middle stage that some find off-putting. While Xerjoff as a house receives strong praise from dedicated fans, specific opinions on Indochine are limited, suggesting it may appeal primarily to adventurous fragrance collectors rather than mainstream audiences.

Mamluk receives minimal but positive mention in the r/fragrance community, praised primarily as an atypical Xerjoff release that avoids the brand's signature sweetness. Community members appreciate its tobacco-citrus profile as a refreshing alternative to the Casamorati line's gourmand tendencies, though limited discussion suggests it remains relatively under-the-radar compared to other fragrances in the brand.