Isabey L'ambre de Carthage vs Chergui

Grand Soir is a divisive fragrance that generates strong mixed reactions within the community. While admirers praise its complex spicy-amber profile and longevity, detractors find the opening heavy and off-putting, with some describing it as feminine or reminiscent of unpleasant body odor. The fragrance requires multiple wearings to appreciate and is best suited for those with adventurous tastes in unconventional scents.

Chergui is a well-crafted but divisive fragrance with a distinctive powdery tobacco profile that appeals strongly to its admirers but isn't universally loved. The community consensus leans positive overall, though most agree it's not a safe blind buy given its niche character and high price point, recommending sampling first, especially if coming from different fragrance families like Ambre Sultan.