When the Rain Stops vs By the Fireplace

The r/fragrance community shows cautious interest in "When the Rain Stops" but with reservations about whether it lives up to its rain-inspired concept. While some users are excited about the fragrance and brand prestige, multiple commenters note it smells more musky and plant-like than true petrichor, making sampling recommended over blind buying. Supply issues on Sephora further complicated early availability.

By the Fireplace receives mixed community sentiment, with users recognizing it as a distinctive fragrance that works best in specific contexts. While some appreciate its unique character, the consensus suggests it's primarily suited for evening or casual wear rather than office environments, and requires careful application to avoid overwhelming those nearby.