Rrose vs Sci Fi

Ellis Brooklyn RRose receives mixed community feedback, with some praising it as an affordable dupe for expensive rose fragrances like MFK A la Rose. However, others find the synthetic rose note unpleasant, describing it as smelling like aged cheese or parmesan. The overall consensus is that it's a decent budget-friendly option for rose lovers, though individual nose chemistry significantly affects whether the fragrance smells pleasant or off-putting.

Sci Fi is widely praised as Ellis Brooklyn's most unique offering, with a distinctive cool-sweet profile that feels genuinely original to many in the community. While most appreciate its balanced composition of citrus, green tea, and creamy vanilla, some experience disappointing longevity and find it overly sweet, making it a fragrance that benefits from trying before purchasing.