Royal Mayfair vs Original Vetiver

Royal Mayfair is a deeply divisive Creed fragrance celebrated by devoted fans for its unique, regal character and excellent longevity, but widely cautioned against as a blind buy due to its challenging medicinal and eucalyptus-forward profile. Many users report initial dislike that transforms into appreciation with repeated wearings, making sampling essential before committing to a full bottle.

Original Vetiver is highly regarded by the r/fragrance community as a standout Creed fragrance that offers exceptional versatility and unique character. While most users praise its clean, soapy profile and broad appeal across genders and occasions, some report longevity inconsistencies and note it requires time to fully appreciate. The community consensus is that it represents one of Creed's best offerings and worthy of its premium price point for those seeking a distinctive, all-purpose scent.