South Water vs 1270

South Water by Lili Bermuda received negative feedback from a Reddit user with parosmia who reported the fragrance became nauseating and unpleasant-smelling after COVID-related smell distortion. The user abandoned this perfume due to sensory intolerance, though this appears to be a condition-specific issue rather than a general product quality problem.

The community appreciates 1270's distinctive warm, sweet character and finds it genuinely appealing, but consensus criticism centers on its disappointing longevity that doesn't justify its premium price. While some consider it a personal favorite worth the effort, many have given up on it due to the need for constant respraying throughout the day.