Annabel's Birthday Cake vs Lira

The community consensus on Annabel's Birthday Cake is cautiously positive, with users appreciating its balanced sweetness and subtle floral-vanilla-citrus profile. While it's described as a pleasant surprise and worth trying, the fragrance appears to be a solid niche offering rather than a standout piece in most collections.

Xerjoff Lira is a polarizing gourmand fragrance that impresses devoted fans with its delicious cake-like scent, interesting supporting notes, and strong projection, but frustrates others with its cloying sweetness, play-doh undertones, and high price-to-performance ratio. Community consensus is that it's excellent for gourmand enthusiasts who enjoy extremely sweet fragrances and don't mind moderate longevity, but requires careful sampling before purchase.