212 Sexy vs Black XS for Her

212 Sexy by Carolina Herrera receives minimal positive discussion in the r/fragrance community. The only mentions found users who received it as a gift and actively sought to swap or sell the bottles, indicating low satisfaction among fragrance enthusiasts despite its accessibility as a designer option.

Black XS for Her (original) is remembered fondly by the community as a well-balanced sweet fragrance with dark, comforting notes that prevent it from being overly feminine. However, the discontinuation of the original formulation and reported formula changes in current releases have made it harder to recommend as a current purchase, though it remains a benchmark comparison for similar scents.