Gardenia לעומת White Diamonds

Elizabeth Taylor Gardenia received overwhelmingly negative feedback from the r/fragrance community, with the original poster describing it as putrid and artificial despite liking the natural scent of gardenias. Multiple commenters reported similar experiences of artificial-smelling fragrances causing physical nausea, making this a fragrance to avoid for most users.

White Diamonds is fondly remembered as a nostalgic childhood fragrance with strong positive associations, though the community acknowledges it is quite pungent and requires restraint in application. The fragrance appeals primarily to those who love classic aldehydes and vintage scents, with some younger enthusiasts rediscovering it as part of 90s aesthetic trends. Overall, the community views it positively as a legitimate classic, though with the caveat that it demands respect in dosage.