Dirty Hinoki לעומת The Noir 29

Dirty Hinoki is a baffling fragrance that confuses many wearers by smelling nothing like its listed woody-citrus notes, with some detecting cotton candy or sweet lemon cake instead. While the community finds it genuinely pleasant and interesting despite—or because of—this disconnect, it remains a divisive and unpredictable fragrance that performs very differently across individuals.

The Noir 29 is highly praised by the community as an emotionally resonant, sophisticated fragrance with a complex development and impressive dry down that receives consistent compliments. The primary complaint centers on its premium pricing and slower opening, though those who appreciate Le Labo's long-game approach consider it well worth the investment for its unique, enchanting character.