Altamir לעומת Pi

The community views the new Gaultier2 as a decent fragrance in its own right, with solid performance and compliment-worthy qualities, but acknowledges it's a noticeably softer, more diluted version of the original. While some defend it as worthwhile at retail price, others criticize it as a mediocre reformulation that doesn't live up to the legacy of the classic.

Givenchy Pi is beloved for its beautiful, versatile scent profile but consistently criticized for weak performance and suspected reformulation over the decades. The community consensus is that it's worth buying for the attractive fragrance itself, but buyers should accept that it requires multiple sprays and frequent reapplication rather than expecting strong projection or longevity.