Xtra Milk vs Not A Perfume — Comparaison de parfums | Fraganty
Xtra Milk vs Not A Perfume
Comparaison côte à côte de Xtra Milk par DedCool et Not A Perfume par Juliette Has A Gun
DedCool
2022feminine
4.03(1,223)
Accords
Juliette Has A Gun
2010feminine
3.76(13,522)
Accords
Résumé de la comparaison
Accords communs (2)
MusquéAmbré
Attribut
Xtra Milk
Not A Perfume
Marque
DedCool
Juliette Has A Gun
Année
2022
2010
Évaluation
4.03
3.76
Concentration
—
—
Genre
feminine
feminine
Total des notes
0
0
Pouls du sentiment communautaire — Xtra Milk
Négatif
27 avis · Source : communauté r/fragrance
3.5
/10
Le consensus communautaire est que DedCool Xtra Milk a subi un changement négatif significatif, les achats récents sentant l'alcool ou n'ayant pratiquement aucun parfum, comparé aux anciennes formulations bien-aimées. De nombreux utilisateurs signalent leur frustration face aux réponses faibles du service client suggérant un « temps de macération » ou un secouage du flacon. Bien que certains connaissent toujours des résultats positifs, les plaintes généralisées concernant la faible tenue, la projection faible et les apparentes reformulations ou défaillances du contrôle de qualité dominent les discussions récentes.
Positif
Beautiful, complimented musk scent when it works
Clean laundry/skin scent quality appeals to some
Beloved by loyal fans who had older formulations
Négatif
Recent bottles smell like rubbing alcohol or have no scent at all
Very poor longevity and weak projection
Pouls du sentiment communautaire — Not A Perfume
Mitigé
79 avis · Source : communauté r/fragrance
5.5
/10
Not A Perfume est extrêmement divisif, les réactions variant considérablement entre l'amour et la haine selon la chimie cutanée individuelle et l'anosmie génétique potentielle à ses molécules clés. Le parfum fonctionne magnifiquement pour certains porteurs qui le trouvent réconfortant et reçoivent des compliments, mais d'autres l'expérimentent comme désagréablement piquant ou ne peuvent pas le sentir du tout, ce qui en fait l'un des parfums les plus imprévisibles de la communauté.
Positif
Unique skin scent that smells different on everyone based on chemistry
Grows on you over time with repeated wear
Receives genuine compliments despite wearer's personal dislike
Warm, clean, and comforting for those who connect with it
Négatif
Highly polarizing - some people smell nothing at all due to anosmia
Questions fréquentes
What's the difference between Xtra Milk and Not A Perfume?+
Xtra Milk is a feminine fragrance (marketed to women, though wearable by all) from DedCool (2022) dominated by Musky accords. Not A Perfume is a feminine fragrance (marketed to women, though wearable by all) from Juliette Has A Gun (2010) leaning on Amber accords. They share 2 accords: Musky, Amber.
Musqué
100%
Poudré
59%
Ambré
49%
Animalique
25%
Agrume
21%
Frais épicé
10%
Meilleur: Spring (89%)Day (100%)
Ambré
100%
Boisé
70%
Musqué
60%
Balsamique
50%
Épicé chaud
30%
Meilleur: Spring (87%)Day (100%)
Which is better, Xtra Milk or Not A Perfume?+
By community rating, Xtra Milk scores 4.03/5 vs Not A Perfume at 3.76/5. On r/fragrance, Xtra Milk sits at 3.5/10 (negative) while Not A Perfume is 5.5/10 (mixed). Xtra Milk's standout strength: Beautiful, complimented musk scent when it works. Not A Perfume's standout strength: Unique skin scent that smells different on everyone based on chemistry. The "better" choice depends on what you value — longevity, projection, season fit, or signature character.
Do Xtra Milk and Not A Perfume smell similar?+
They share a small fraction of their ingredients — expect noticeably different experiences. Xtra Milk: Le consensus communautaire est que DedCool Xtra Milk a subi un changement négatif significatif, les achats récents sentant l'alcool ou n'ayant pratiquement aucun parfum, comparé aux anciennes formulations bien-aimées. Not A Perfume: Not A Perfume est extrêmement divisif, les réactions variant considérablement entre l'amour et la haine selon la chimie cutanée individuelle et l'anosmie génétique potentielle à ses molécules clés.
Which lasts longer, Xtra Milk or Not A Perfume?+
Xtra Milk: Very poor longevity and weak projection Longevity varies by skin chemistry, concentration, and application method.
Which season suits Xtra Milk vs Not A Perfume?+
Xtra Milk scores highest for spring wear; Not A Perfume scores highest for spring wear. Xtra Milk leans daytime, Not A Perfume leans daytime.
Formula appears to have changed or quality control issues
Poor customer service with dismissive responses
Others experience it as sharp, caustic, or unpleasant (burning plastic, chemicals, vinegar)
High concentration of polarizing molecules (Cetalox, Ambroxan) that trigger negative reactions
Potential genetic or sensory factors make it unpredictable