What's the difference between Melancholy Thistle and Black Phantom?+
Melancholy Thistle is a feminine fragrance (marketed to women, though wearable by all) from Jo Malone London (2023) dominated by Woody accords. Black Phantom is a feminine fragrance (marketed to women, though wearable by all) from By Kilian (2017) leaning on Sweet accords. They share 2 accords: Woody, Warm Spicy.
Which is better, Melancholy Thistle or Black Phantom?+
By community rating, Melancholy Thistle scores 3.99/5 vs Black Phantom at 4.08/5. Black Phantom's standout strength: Great performance and longevity. The "better" choice depends on what you value — longevity, projection, season fit, or signature character.
Do Melancholy Thistle and Black Phantom smell similar?+
They share a small fraction of their ingredients — expect noticeably different experiences. Black Phantom: Black Phantom est un parfum gourmand diviseur avec une performance puissante qui plaît à certains mais déçoit d'autres qui le trouvent trop écœurant et survendu.
Which lasts longer, Melancholy Thistle or Black Phantom?+
Black Phantom: Great performance and longevity Longevity varies by skin chemistry, concentration, and application method.
Which season suits Melancholy Thistle vs Black Phantom?+
Melancholy Thistle scores highest for spring wear; Black Phantom scores highest for winter wear. Melancholy Thistle leans daytime, Black Phantom leans evening.
