Tobacco Oud vs Herod

The r/fragrance community views Tobacco Oud very positively as a powerhouse winter fragrance with exceptional longevity and distinctive whiskey-tobacco character. However, discontinuation rumors and availability concerns persist, with some users reporting batch variations and reformulations. Many collectors are using their bottles actively rather than hoarding due to uncertainty about future availability.

Herod is highly regarded in the community as a top-tier fragrance from Parfums de Marly, praised for its complex vanilla-tobacco profile, smooth character, and impressive longevity. While some users report moderate projection rather than extreme performance, the consensus is that it offers excellent quality, especially when purchased on sale, though buyers should verify authenticity due to counterfeits in the market.