Secret de Rochas vs Casmir

The r/fragrance community has a passionate subgroup of rose fragrance lovers who appreciate the diversity and versatility of rose-based scents. While vintage rose fragrances and reformulations are a source of frustration, the community actively recommends affordable alternatives and niche options that deliver quality rose experiences. The overall sentiment is enthusiastic about rose fragrances despite challenges in sourcing original versions.

Chopard Casmir is a polarizing 1991 fragrance with devoted fans who appreciate its creamy vanilla-amber-sandalwood base, though opinions are divided on the fruity-spicy top notes which can amplify differently depending on individual skin chemistry. The fragrance's performance and character vary notably between different production versions, making it a somewhat inconsistent choice but worthwhile for those seeking classic gourmand compositions.