Judith vs Y

Σύγκριση πλάι-πλάι του Judith από Judith Muller και Y από Yves Saint Laurent

Judith Muller

1975feminine

3.67(12)

Ακόρντα

Yves Saint Laurent

1964feminine

4.17(1,237)

Ακόρντα

Σύνοψη σύγκρισης

Κοινά ακόρντα (3)

ΞυλώδεςΑνθικόΦρουτώδες

Χαρακτηριστικό	Judith	Y
Οίκος	Judith Muller	Yves Saint Laurent
Έτος	1975	1964
Βαθμολογία	3.67	4.17
Συγκέντρωση	—	—
Φύλο	feminine	feminine
Σύνολο νοτών	21	21

Συχνές ερωτήσεις

What's the difference between Judith and Y?+

Judith is a feminine fragrance (marketed to women, though wearable by all) from Judith Muller (1975) dominated by Woody accords. Y is a feminine fragrance (marketed to women, though wearable by all) from Yves Saint Laurent (1964) leaning on Green accords. They share 3 accords: Woody, Floral, Fruity.

Which is better, Judith or Y?+

By community rating, Judith scores 3.67/5 vs Y at 4.17/5. Y's standout strength: Good performance and projection. The "better" choice depends on what you value — longevity, projection, season fit, or signature character.

Do Judith and Y smell similar?+

They share 9 notes and 3 accords, including Woody, Floral, Fruity, Aldehydes, Hyacinth. Y: YSL Y EDP is a polarizing fragrance with decent performance that receives external compliments but is personally disliked by many wearers.

Which lasts longer, Judith or Y?+

Y: Good performance and projection Longevity varies by skin chemistry, concentration, and application method.

Which season suits Judith vs Y?+

Judith scores highest for all seasons wear; Y scores highest for spring wear. Judith leans daytime, Y leans daytime.

Παλμός συναισθήματος κοινότητας — Y

Μεικτό

30 γνώμες · Πηγή: κοινότητα r/fragrance

6.2

/10

YSL Y EDP is a polarizing fragrance with decent performance that receives external compliments but is personally disliked by many wearers. The fragrance is criticized for its sharp, piercing opening and synthetic character, though some appreciate it as a reliable, versatile everyday scent. Many recommend exploring alternatives like Dior Sauvage or trying the Le Parfum concentration instead.

Θετικό

Good performance and projection
Versatile and safe everyday fragrance
Gets compliments from others
Clean bottle design and decent value

Αρνητικό

Sharp, piercing, and loud opening that can be obnoxious
Strong apple and ginger notes feel screechy to some
Synthetic and uninspired quality
Highly divisive - not liked on skin by many despite external compliments

Judith vs Y

Σύνοψη σύγκρισης

Κοινές νότες (9)

Μοναδικές στο Judith (12)

Μοναδικές στο Y (12)

Κοινά ακόρντα (3)

Συχνές ερωτήσεις

Θετικό

Αρνητικό