Winter of '99 vs Blackmail

Winter of '99 by Kerosene appears to be a solid cold-weather fragrance that appeals to niche fragrance enthusiasts, as evidenced by its inclusion in community wear tracking. However, community feedback suggests it has a heavy-handed quality that some find excessive, and it receives less enthusiastic acclaim compared to other Kerosene releases.

Blackmail is highly regarded within the Kerosene enthusiast community as a distinctive, well-crafted fragrance with a captivating smoky character. Community members consistently praise its quality and unique scent profile, with multiple users expressing strong intent to purchase it, though the niche house and polarizing smoky notes mean it appeals to a specific audience rather than mass market appeal.