Paul Smith Man vs Le Male

The community views Paul Smith Man (original green bottle) as a quality classic fragrance with a distinctive dry, green character that works well for professional and seasonal wear. While not extensively discussed in these posts, it's mentioned favorably as a comparable scent to discontinued fragrances like Creed Green Valley, indicating solid performance and versatility.

Le Male Le Parfum is a divisive fragrance with a devoted fanbase who love its sweet, warm character and strong projection, but significant detractors who find it overly sugary, generic, and lacking in sophistication. The fragrance's appeal is highly subjective and dependent on individual skin chemistry and personal preference for gourmand scents.