Paul Smith Man vs A*Men Pure Havane

The community views Paul Smith Man (original green bottle) as a quality classic fragrance with a distinctive dry, green character that works well for professional and seasonal wear. While not extensively discussed in these posts, it's mentioned favorably as a comparable scent to discontinued fragrances like Creed Green Valley, indicating solid performance and versatility.

The r/fragrance community sees Pure Havane as a more versatile and wearable alternative to the overhyped Pure Malt, with a pleasant drydown and good compliment-generating potential. However, concerns about recent reformulation affecting longevity and weak sillage are common complaints that detract from its overall appeal.