Must de Cartier Gold vs Obsession

Must de Cartier Gold is viewed as a competent modern fragrance but controversial as a flanker of the original. The community consensus is that while it's sympathetically done and works as a standalone scent, it strays too far from the original with excessive vanilla and lost complexity, making it feel disconnected from its heritage rather than a proper modernization.

The r/fragrance community holds Obsession in generally favorable regard, particularly for its distinctive cinnamon and spicy character that differentiates it from mainstream fragrances. However, there is significant disappointment with the modern reformulation, with many preferring vintage bottles despite their rarity and high cost. The consensus is that if you enjoy the scent, wearing it remains relevant regardless of trends, provided application is moderate.