Mandragore Pourpre vs Nuit Etoilee

The community consensus is that the original Mandragore has been discontinued, disappointing loyal users. While Mandragore Pourpre is positioned as a successor featuring star anise and patchouli notes, it appears to be a reformulation rather than a direct replacement, leaving fans uncertain about whether the new version will satisfy those who loved the original.

Nuit Etoilee is a discontinued Goutal fragrance that holds nostalgic value for those who wore it, particularly remembered for rainy weather wear. While appreciated by those who experienced it, the community consensus is mixed due to its discontinuation status and the difficulty in sourcing bottles, though a dupe alternative (Parfums Vintage Imbue) exists.