Altamir vs Obsession for Men

The community views the new Gaultier2 as a decent fragrance in its own right, with solid performance and compliment-worthy qualities, but acknowledges it's a noticeably softer, more diluted version of the original. While some defend it as worthwhile at retail price, others criticize it as a mediocre reformulation that doesn't live up to the legacy of the classic.

The r/fragrance community views Obsession for Men as a genuine classic with a unique spicy-cinnamon profile that differentiates it from typical colognes. While some appreciate its timeless relevance and broad appeal, others consider it dated, though this hasn't diminished its appeal among loyal wearers who prioritize personal preference over trends.