All Good Things vs Dirty

All Good Things by Lush has a challenging opening that mellows with wear, making it a fragrance that rewards patience and repeated testing. Community reception is limited but suggests it may appeal to those willing to let a scent develop over time rather than make an immediate judgment.

Lush Dirty is a divisive fragrance that appeals to some for its fresh mint and herbal qualities with an interesting anise twist, making it a good budget-friendly entry point for new fragrance enthusiasts. However, the community consensus notes it suffers from poor longevity and can feel inexpensive over time, leading many to seek out more premium alternatives with similar scent profiles.